

Barca v Man U, a.k.a. “The Big One” 1:30 p.m. CT, ESPN2
By: Kevin | April 22nd, 2008
You know why this man is smiling? Because he is thinking about getting in some Red Devil ass, that’s why. Because this is it. The real deal, and he is the most pivotal player on the pitch for so many reasons, but most importantly, because they can’t score if they don’t have the ball. If we are playing our possession game well, Yaya is a pivotal part, with his intelligent passes out of the back, deft footwork and physical presence.
Also, much Man U attacking comes up the middle, and Yaya is going to be even more important with El Capitan, Puyol, sitting out a red card that should have been rolled up into a tight little cylinder and shoved up Eric Abidal’s erratic ass.
Thankfully, we are at home, which should be worth something that will, hopefully, make up for the absence of our man. I’d be a lot more confident if Puyol were in the side tomorrow. But as it is, I’m still feeling pretty good.
The squad is Valdes, Milito, Thuram, Marquez, Xavi, Gudjohnsen, Iniesta, Eto’o, Pinto, Henry, Sylvinho, Messi, Deco, Dos Santos, Krkic, Abidal, Zambrotta.
Who is the name we are most excited to see on that list? You got it, folks….DECOOOOO! If he is back….I mean really and fully back, not the sullen, unshaven, card-nabbing cipher he has been this season, the Red Devils are in trouble. Because suddenly, Iniesta is freed up to become a real attacker, playing off Messi and Eto’o, taking great passes from Deco, who also tracks back on defense.
Which brings us to the question of the day: Do we play it safe and tight at home, or do we go for the jugular, counting on them being nervous on the road? You know what I say. Put the knife in, and let’s go down playing our best game. With that in mind, here’s my ideal starting XI:
Valdes, Milito, Thuram, Sylvinho, Abidal, Yaya, Deco, Xavi, Iniesta, Messi, Henry. My three second-half subs are: Marquez, Eto’o, and Krkic.
Put Henry in the middle of the damn pitch, where he belongs, and turn him loose. Man U remembers his killer days from Arsenal. They WILL be nervous. I’m moving Deco up, right behind Iniesta, Messi and Henry and pressing. Xavi and Yaya are very solid in the middle, and I like Thuram’s big-game experience. He’ll be able to call Abidal a dumbass en Francais, and calm him down.
Then leave the back line at home, give Valdes some puppy uppers, and stay away from Ronaldo’s flopping ass. If you have to foul him, make it a good one so that he at least earns the rolling around on the pitch that he’s going to be doing.
Now, for another reason Yaya is important: Frustrating Wayne Rooney and taking him out of his game. Rooney HATES big, physical defenders with great feet. He plays a physical, pugnacious game himself and likes being the only one to do so.
The way that the game is called will be critical. Distressingly, Yaya, Messi, Marquez and Milito are all a yellow card away from a suspension. You’d think that with such a match, the ref would just let them play. We’ll see.
The play of Messi, and the way that we start out, is going to be very important. Both Eto’o and Henry have had trouble finishing, but I would take Henry in the starting XI in a heartbeat. Rijkaard will probably play it safe, but to hell with him.
If we concede free kicks near our area, we are in trouble. Ball control will be critical, and Abidal is going to have to be ON.
Okay, enough of this. It’s go time.
Subscribe
|
Print
|
Share
![]() |
Comments
-



Go Barca. Hoping for a 2-0 win. It’s the Nou Camp. Barca will rise.
Plus, the question of putting Man United to it’s place.
Posted from
India

-



I don’t like the suggested starting lineup. I’m thinking more like:
Valdes, Zambrotta, Marquez, Milito, Abidal, Toure, Xavi, Iniesta, Messi, Eto’o, Krkic
The reason for this is that let the kids play together as they do so well, let Iniesta build with Bojan and Eto’o while Messi slaughters their wingbacks and combines with Xavi and Zambrotta. Don’t forget that Zambys plays about 800 times better with Messi to give him space down the right for those crosses by distracting the defenders.
Deco shouldn’t get the start simply because he hasn’t played. The likelihood of a bum game is much higher because you haven’t played for a while, but maybe we’ll see him come off the bench.
I don’t think either team will crush the other, so it’s going to be tough. I’m still saying 2-1 us, though, because of Messi.
Posted from
United States

-



I’m hoping Barca come out and attack, full-on at Man United, purely because United do tend to play it safe away from home. They’ll probably line up 4-5-1 so if Barca do want to stick the knife in tonight, I think there is a real chance for them to.
Posted from
United Kingdom

-



Isaiah, I like your lineup, but I think that Iniesta is so much more effective in an attacking role. And I also think that Henry will be somewhat of a secret weapon against ManU- he knows how to beat them.
I do agree with 2-1 to us, though.
Posted from
Australia

-



I’m still digging Thuram in there because he’s a great position defender who knows his limitations. No roaming and getting caught out of position, which will be critical to keep Man U in check at the back line. Our back line will have to stay put and not screw around.
Krkic is doing very well, and will be a great player. But this isn’t the place for him to start. There’s too much on the line. The moment is too big. I’d start him at Old Trafford, actually. But there’s so much pressure at home.
It’s good to have Krkic come in once the match is under way as an energizing factor, but the physicality of Man U’s defense, fresh as they will be in the first half, would remove any possibility of him being truly effective. Size does matter sometimes. In the second half, when legs are a little heavier, he can be more effective.
This is also true of Eto’o. Try those parlor tricks that he tries in La Liga and Rio Ferdinand will knock him on his ass. He’ll then get petulant, and try them ever more, and in effect remove himself from the match. We can’t have that stuff today.
No, a match and moment such as this one is a time for the tried-and-true, the lads who have been there before, know what it’s like and won’t get the willies. Thuram. Henry. Deco.
My subs are Marquez for Thuram, Eto’o for Henry and Krkic for Iniesta. Deco better not get tired.
The reason I would start Deco is because I think that he’s always been better in the starting lineup rather than coming off the bench, and we need him to be good. Were I Rijkaard, I wouldn’t really care who has been there, or injured, or whatever. I’d want the lineup that gives us the best chance of victory. I’d take Zambrotta over Sylvinho if somebody made it clear to Zambrotta that he has to stay the hell home and not get caught far upfield as he has been of late. He doesn’t have the pace to deal with the Man U counters, which are as fast as anyone’s in the world right now.
Make no mistake, it is far more important to not concede than to put in a lot of goals. A 1-0 or 2-0 win would put me over the moon. Away goals kill you in home/away ties.
Is it time yet?
Posted from
United States

-



You say tried-and-true, Kevin, but how are Henry, Deco, and Thuram more “true” than Marquez, Krkic, and Eto’o?
Is it goals scored? Is it goals conceded? In no statistical category does that lineup lead the other one and in goals scored Eto’o crushes Henry. Granted, Marquez has had few starts this year, so I expect Thuram to start, but I want Marquez to start. Thuram is solid, yes, but we’re not in it for solid right now. This is do or die. Put up or shut up. Shit or get off the pot. And Thuram is solid, but not capable of a great game. Marquez has more variables, but can have a great game. You’ll get a solid performance out of Thuram, but no upside, no potential for scoring the game-winner, for dropping that inch-perfect pass onto someone’s foot. And Marquez does have those qualities, even if he has the capability of having a stinker too.
In a perfect world, this is a cakewalk, because Henry and Deco would smash shit up all over the place, but this is not a perfect world. Henry is not Henry these days and Deco has not played in a very long time (when was the last time he played? I can’t even remember right now)
So I think we should start our best lineup based on performance and continuity. I understand the argument saying that Bojan should start on the bench because of the physical nature of ManU, but who would replace him? Eto’o has to start with a goalscoring record like he has since returning from injury(something like 14 goals in 15 games?) and as far as I’ve seen, no one disputes the claim that he and Henry don’t play well together. Let him do his thing and then put Henry on in the second half to go all out.
Remember, we have Messi on the right, so that solves our right-side problems. Messi and Eto’o play well together and the former creates a ton of space for the latter in the box. Pushing Xavi and Iniesta up (especially Iniesta) will just add to the attack. Bojan on the left is another on-the-ball wonder, so let him run at opponents from the left, especially since he’ll be able to lay the ball of for Iniesta at the top of the box or Eto’o in the middle.
Henry would require a 4-4-2 and that’s not happening, so why bother forcing something that just isn’t there at the moment?
Posted from
United States

-



I’m a Real Madrid fan. I’m hoping that Barca put out a great performance tonight and show ManU what Spanish football is capable of. Good Luck.
Posted from
United States

-



But you’re being logical. Psychology isn’t all that logical. Remember Memphis/Kansas. Big players rise to big moments. Chalmers’ game-tying, off-balance three? Junior. Derrick Rose’s critical, clunky free throws with the game on the line? Freshman.
This is a big moment. Giant. And I don’t want it in the hands of a kid or a potentially petulant striker. I think that both have the potential to change a game that is already under way with their pace and aggression, most definitely.
Deco is the wild card there, because he won’t be fully match fit. You can’t be, no matter how hard you practice. But in his role, he won’t really have to be.
And keep in mind that we don’t need Thuram to have a great game. We need for Thuram to do what he does: stay put and play great position defense. Marquez might be great, he might be shit. Risky. Thuram is always solid, because that’s what he does.
If this were a league game, or even El Clasico, I’d say rock on. Start the kid, start Eto’o and Marquez, bring Deco off the bench. But this is big. Huge. I just don’t think we can have players in there who might be overcome by the moment.
I’m sure that Rijkaard is having the same discussions in his mind, and with his assistants. We don’t have long to find out the answers.
My stomach is in knots.
Posted from
United States

-



I won’t argue that I prefer the experience to the youth when all things are equal, but right now they’re not equal. If Henry could play well with Eto’o, then I’d go with Henry no questions asked, but it’s not that way. We’ll see who Rijkaard listens to, though. I’m guess neither and he starts a lineup with Guddie in it.
Also, on the basketball note, besides that being a cheap shot
you’re wrong. Derrick Rose missed ONE free throw. Chris Douglas-Roberts missed THREE. Douglas-Roberts was the junior, the man, the superduperstar, the go-to guy. Like Chalmers, only Chalmers came through. That’s how it goes sometimes. “The shot into blue heaven” they’re calling it in Jayhawk land.Maybe Bojan can pull off something like that, but I suspect it’ll be the third-year man for Barcelona: Messi.
Posted from
United States

-



the game nears, and the starting 11 has been announced on the FCB website. more grist for the mill.
goalie Valdes
back line Zamby, Marquez, Milito, Abidal
defensive mid YAYA
mids Xavi Deco Iniesta
forwards Eto and Messino thuram or henry or bojan, but nice to have them on the bench! i like the 4-4-2 for this match, though its not even a pure 4-4-2 i suppose. will be interesting to see what iniesta does.
Posted from
United States

-



Krkic might be better coming off the bench, depending on how much time he’s given. He’ll come into a game with some tired midfield legs out there and be able to take full advantage of his youth and athleticism. Almost here now. Good luck to Barcelona.
Posted from
United States

-



Well, at least I got most of it right. I’m a genius!!!
Interesting that we’re going to start with a 4-4-2, essentially…or even a 4-1-4-1 if you think about it…hmmm
I AM SO EXCITED and now I have to sign off the internets and not look at another thing until I get home and start the game from the top.
Posted from
United States

-



By the way, the game is on ESPN Classic at 5 EST, for those of you with that channel, no DVR, and work until just before that.
Posted from
United States

-



Kxevin: just finished reading your post after posting some comments on the offside homepage - and we’re of a like mind. Barce need to attack, Yaya and midfield need to control.
The great line-up debate you guys have going here is fascinating - there are some real headscratchers. But I have to agree with Isaiah on this one. Xavi, right now, is the man with the experience that counts, not Deco. Xavi’s played the CL before, knows what to expect, and has playing experience this season that Deco’s missed. And, so many times this year, Xavi’s bailed his side out when it mattered most. As for Henry - while he may know how to play Man U, Man U also know how to play him. Not so with Krkic. (Read: secret weapon)
Finally, if Eto’o’s getting manhandled and is proving ineffective, what better sub could you wish for than Henry? (Well, maybe Raul, but…) Subbing in Thiery into the middle late in the match might really strike fear in the hearts of the Red Devils.
Anyways, Evo and Ian Rose summed up my feelings about this match. Good luck to your boys out there!
Posted from
United States

-



oh. I see ballbeav posted the official XI and all is settled. I actually think that’s a pretty clever midfield. Here’s hoping…
Posted from
United States

-



VAMOS BARCE! No All England Final. MESSI MAKE US PROUD!
Posted from
United States

-



I feel good about the next leg.. let’s hope we can SCORE in Old Trafford. Plus Puyol will be with us

Posted from
United States

-



Same here, Joe. I really think we can pull it off. We absolutely dominated this game, so why can’t we do it again?
Posted from
Australia

-



You know a blog is good when one of the first things you want to do after the game is read its review… hehe.
Posted from
United States

-



Btb, anyone else feel Henry deserved an earlier start… or at least starting from the get-go a OT? He was on for 15 min and gave Van der Saar two huge scares

Posted from
United States

-



Joe, I’m glad that you like the blog this much. I’ll be throwing up a detailed review either later tonight or early tomorrow.
Right now, though, I’d like to say that Samu, my man in the mdiddle, the guy I have supported when others called for Henry to start, suuucked tonight. Good lord.
Posted from
United States

-



I wasn’t going to bring that up Isaiah, but now that you mention it, “sucked” is being generous. If Henry gets that start, it does not end 0-0. By the time he came on, Man U were playing for the draw.
Right you are, Joe. And Deco played GREAT. But Yaya was MOTM for my dosh.
Posted from
United States

-



Disagree that Deco was great. Overstatement, I think. Great is scoring or creating a goal. He was good. Solid, but not special. Not his fault, of course, and he did well considering, but great? No way.
Yeah, Samu was doodoo, but Henry couldn’t get the start cause he was recovering from a fever.
Posted from
United States

-



But Deco filled his role of keeping the ball moving forward and completing pass after delightful one-touch pass. Iniesta, Messi and Eto’o are supposed to be putting the ball in the net. He fought for balls and kept possession many a time, feeding it to Messi or someone to do something more. That they didn’t isn’t Deco’s fault.
Posted from
United States

-



Oh, and Rose missed the crucial one, to put Memphis up by four, if I recall correctly. Of course, if it was Douglas-Roberts, I stand corrected and will kick myself.
Posted from
United States

Read the rest of the comments
Comments are closed
















