Champions League review: FC Barcelona 2 – 1 Celtic: Leaving it ’til the Last Minute: A Masterclass

By: Natasha | October 24th, 2012
   
But what I'd really like to know is where to buy one of those big inflatable...things...to the very right of this picture.

But what I'd really like to know is where to buy one of those big inflatable...things...to the very right of this picture.

There was a time when Barça would produce 5-0 scorelines on the regular and there was no such thing as a 4-5 result or a winning goal within the last 30 seconds of injury time. Looks like those days are gone! Better invest in some paper bags to breathe into…

Barça’s lineup was as follows: Valdes – Adriano, Bartra, Mascherano, Alba – Xavi, Song, Iniesta, – Pedro, Messi, Alexis. After playing a great match at the weekend, Cesc was benched. Apparently that’s how it works at Barça! Bartra finally got a start and is no longer JDS version 2.0, which is a relief, because he did rather well. I almost expected Messi to start on the bench because if he were to be rested, this would be the match to do it, most likely…and because there was much talk in the Scottish newspapers of “neutralizing Messi”, which was actually quite effective in the end.

So this match was supposed to be an easy win for Barça – playing at home (at the “New Camp”, as my commentators liked to call it) and against a team who didn’t have a chance in the CL anyway, according to some. Maybe that was the problem? Most of us will have noticed that Barça became complacent quite a few times last season. But I don’t think that was it, I think it was simply a case of Barça facing a strong team, one with an especially tough defence. We know what happens when Barça face a team with a tough defence…remember Chelsea? Yup.

And before we knew it, Celtic scored. Or rather, Mascherano had quite a part to play here. Maybe he’s going for the own goal Pichichi trophy? Looks like he’s suffering from a dip in form, probably because he’s the only “experienced centre back” we have at the moment. The pressure! And this brings me to Bartra. Barça had 82% possession during this match and the defence were mainly untested, but he played very well. Hopefully we’ll see Tito start him more often, maybe alongside Puyol or Piqué, because he needs time to develop. We’ll see how he copes against a team that are constantly attacking, but so far, so good.

In true Barça style (for this match), their first goal came at the very end of the first half. But it was worth waiting for. After a psychic link-up between Messi, Xavi and Iniesta…bam. 1-1. It was a wonderful team goal and you should watch it again. Here’s the link – do it now. Iniesta was also not at his best during this match, but his goal made up for it. And for the next 48-½ minutes of the second half, it looked like that was all we were getting out of this match.

Our goalscorers holding hands. That's cute. I think.

Our goalscorers holding hands. That's cute. I think.

The first half was a bit of a mess. We saw the majority of the play go straight down the middle again, with Messi acting like a pot of honey to the bees every time he got the ball. Alexis, apart from a shot at goal during the opening minutes, was mainly anonymous. Yet this seems to happen time and time again – where is the wing play? We see it when Dani Alves is on the pitch, usually in the form of crosses being fired into the box with no one to meet them, but we do see it. Jordi Alba plays very well on his flank, but our wingers need to step up. Going through the middle of a congested pitch doesn’t work and goodness knows we’ve seen Barça try and fail to do this on more than one occasion.

The second half had a similar pattern – a shot on target and a save by Celtic’s GK, Forster. There must be something about Barça that allows a goalkeeper to play the match of their life. Remember Javi Varas? Add Forster to that list! He was Celtic’s standout player and his saves were excellent, much to my annoyance. Apart from that, I’m not sure what else I can say about the second half and I lost track of how many shots Barça had after the first, oh, 50.

A draw would have been ideal for Celtic (apart from a win, obviously, but when the game is tied 1-1 at 90 minutes, you’d take the draw too) and I’m guessing most of us Barça fans had given up hope. Desperate times call for desperate measures…enter the Killer Squirrel (thanks, Ade)! The Killer Squirrel being Jordi Alba, of course. I’m not sure how he did it, but he did it, he scored with about 30 seconds left to spare. And if I were a Celtic fan, I’d probably have climbed to the top of the Camp Nou and thrown myself off. Something I find quite funny is that “Alba” is Gaelic for “Scotland”…Alba scored against a Scottish team…get it? Probably not. Maybe it’s only me who finds it funny…

One is a small furry animal, one is Barça's left back. But which is which?

One is a small furry animal, one is Barça's left back. But which is which?

Credit must go to Celtic for playing a clean match and defending with their lives. Whatever their strategy was, it worked, well, almost. If this match was played last season, I think Barça would have walked away with a draw. It looks like there’s a new-found motivation or composure because I haven’t seen the team become complacent like they did last season.

Player ratings

Valdes – 7. Well, he didn’t have much to do and there was no way he could have saved that goal. Mascherano made sure of that!

Adriano – 6. I don’t think he’s anywhere near as good on the right as he is the left and would have preferred Montoya to have started.

Mascherano – 5. Not at his best and after scoring an own goal, I can’t award much more than 5 unfortunately.

Bartra – 7. He did very well and hopefully he’ll start a few more matches this season. As I’ve said though, the main test will be when he’s up against an attacking team.

Jordi Alba – 8. MOTM by far. He saved the match and was tireless on the left. It was a shame there wasn’t better link-up play with Alexis, but Barça insisted on playing straight down the middle for the majority of the match, so that was that ruled out.

Super Squirrel Jordi Alba!

Super Squirrel Jordi Alba!

Song – 7. Not as slick as Busquets is, but he brings something else to the team. Mainly height and willingness to get into the box for a corner. That’s very rare indeed! Song’s first goal is going to be from a set piece. With his head. That is a scientific fact.

Xavi – 7. Part of wonderful play leading up to Iniesta’s goal. Then again, Xavi, creating excellent assists and chances…who’s surprised?

Iniesta – 6. Scored a great goal, yes, but another one who wasn’t at his best. I thought he looked a little tired and he could have been rested for this match instead.

Pedro – 5. Not great either. He didn’t do much on the wing and yes, I keep going on about it, but the wings were completely ignored during this match.

Messi – 6. Celtic wanted to neutralize him and they pretty  much succeeded. There are rumours he was suffering from a cold so that on top of likely jetlag, you can forgive him for not scoring yet another hattrick.

Alexis – 5. Ineffective. I blame play going down the middle of a congested pitch mainly on Alexis and Pedro. He needs to try harder to get past his defender, otherwise, what’s the point? He’s strong enough to do it.

Barça face Celtic in two weeks time at Celtic Park. I think I need those two weeks to recover. How about you?


Some Related Barcelona Posts:


Category Category: Team News
Tags

   
  • Disagree on some of the player ratings.

    Adriano was excellent, as others have pointed out. He had become a fringe player just after he was signed, with Abidal and Maxwell around. However, he has been giving excellent performances since Maxwell departed and Abidal became unavailable. Disagree about him being ineffective on the right. He played brilliantly defensively, and also gave the killer cross for Alba's goal. He is a great utility player. He can play as a full-back as well as as a part of the front three, on either flank. Based on current form, I would rather play Adriano than Alves in the RB position.

    Alba, again, was excellent as an attacking threat down the left, combining nicely with Iniesta. But he left much to be desired defensively. Masche covered the left during the few times Celtic charged down their right. No way was Alba MoM. There were others who played much better. 

    Bartra and Song were brilliant, stopping all their counters. According to WhoScored, Song had 6 tackles and Bartra 5. Both also came close to scoring. While Song s no Busquets when it comes to passing, he is still an excellent player defensively. Maybe even better than Busquets. He has great physicality and is a wonderful tackler. Will be a big success as a CB if he gets his positioning right. Bartra, of course, was excellent too, and deserves more first team football.

    Iniesta. Excellent. Yes, he was anonymous for the first 40 minutes, but then so was almost the entire Barca team. But then in the second half, he was one of the best Barca players. Remember his killer passes to Alexis, Messi and Bartra? For me, he was MoM.

    Alexis and Pedro were ineffective. I think Alexis, and then later Villa, played as a centre forward, with Messi behind him. So no question of playing wide. But even then, Alexis wasn't at his best. Remember the Alexis of last season? Remember his goal in the first Liga clasico last season? Remember his other 14 goals in the league? Where is that Alexis? Pedro, too, didn't play well, but I think much of that was down to Celtic having 10 men inside the box most of the time, so Pedro couldn't cut inside as he usually does. Crosses are anyways not his strongest suit. Maybe he should have attempted more crosses. But Pedro is still one of the best players we have.

    Messi. He played behind the striker, as a number ten. He was deeper than usual in this match. He did make a few key passes in the final third, and came close to scoring twice with his free-kicks, and 67 other times, I guess, most notably through THAT header. (Damn you, Forster!) No way was he as bad as 6/10.

    My personal player ratings:

    VV - 7/10
    Adriano - 8/10
    Bartra - 8/10
    Masche - 5/10
    Alba - 7/10
    Song - 8/10
    Xavi - 8/10
    Iniesta - 9/10 (MoM)
    Messi - 8/10
    Pedro - 6/10
    Alexis - 5/10
    Villa - 7/10 (I know he hit the post.)
    Tello - 7/10

    Also, a few comments about Tito's management. I personally think that while he is a brilliant tactician, his man management is flimsy. look at what he has done to JDS and Bartra. Promoting someone to the first team, and then not playing him even though others at that position are unavailable. Thankfully, Bartra finally got a chance. Wonder when JDS will get one. He's just Mourhinhoing players now, like Mourhinho Mourhinhoed Granero, Sahin, Kaka etc.

    Also, people have been talking about how we are conceding more, scoring less and still winning more. All these are independent things. We are conceding more because Puyol and Pique are injured, and Masche is not at his best due to fatigue probably. Before the Spatak Moscow match when Pique got injured, Barca conceded 1,2,1,2,0,1 (Liga and Super Cup). Since that match, Barca have conceded 2,0,2,0,2,4,1. Wait until Pique and Puyol are back. We will see more clean sheets and fewer goals conceded. Now, coming back to scoring goals. We have scored less this season, but at crucial time, and often when losing. It's hard to pinpoint a reason for this. Last season we used to have regular manitas, but once we got into a losing position, it would be difficult to turn the match around. Apparently that's no more the case. I don't know exactly how much of this phenomenon can be attributed to luck, and how much to Tito's tactics and players' mentality. But the important thing is that we are winning more. Hopefully we will continue to do so, irrespective of luck. We will make our own luck.

  • Ivanmartin118

    And.. about the lack of wing-ness... Tello is the only one that takes it to the plyth. Takes it earthquake weather style to the corner. 

  • Ivanmartin118

    Jordi Alba's head is always tilted back for some reason.  I like this. it's a sign of something. I'm not yet sure of what. 

  • Afakk

    First thing first,  nice photoshop skills you got there.As for the match, well, i really can't stand Alexis.I've been saying this for a year now but im gonna say it again, we should start EVERY game with Tello, without him there is almost no wing action going on.As Kage pointed out in his comment Pedro won't cut it either.I wish Cuenca wasn't injured, he also did his job excellent last year when we needed more width.Also, how is it possible that we concede almost twice as we did last year, score less, bunch of own goals and still going 3/3 in CL and 7½/8 in La Liga.These last minute goals started to become a habit and im really not enjoying it.I wanna watch a Barça match where we can actually win comfortably.Im afraid we cant keep on winning with like this, lack of defensive dicipline and with an above the avarage goal keeper, things are getting tougher every game, boy, how i wish our moc moc twins weren't injured.

  • Natasha

    I don't particularly like Alexis either, always find myself saying "maybe he'll improve", but it hasn't happened...
    Graham Hunter mentioned the late goal thing on his Twitter yesterday - he says it's a mentality the team have and not just a fluke. I'd believe that. The difference from this season to last is that the matches we'd be trailing/drawing last year, we're winning. It seems like there's a renewed motivation within the team to...well, win. I can't say I enjoy watching the team concede so many goals either (my poor nerves...) but whatever Tito is doing, it's working. Hope it stays that way.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Follow Us

           




Spain National Team News

Search The Offside


 




Related Links


Categories


Send Your Tips!

Found a great story, photo or video that's perfect for The Offside?
Email barcelona[at]theoffside[dot]com

Write for The Offside

Archives